The short answer is no.

For years, employees have been encouraged to bring their whole, authentic selves to work. Thought leaders and workplace policies have promoted this idea incessantly. Psychological safety has been touted as the solution to workplace woes, but something always felt off – to me, to us, to people of color participating in the U.S. workforce. It felt like a trap. Like waiting for the other shoe to drop.

We’ve observed that when coworkers said they do experience psychological safety in the workplace, some identities were far more present than others. For example, folks who identify as white, cisgender, straight, middle-to-upper class, college-educated, and who were born and raised in the United States were quick to agree they experienced psychological safety most or all of the time, and seemed surprised when not everyone around them felt the same way.

The current landscape of the U.S. workplace was created by oppressing (enslavement, colonialism, imperialism) and exploiting (capitalism) people of color, more specifically, indigenous, Black, and immigrant populations.

So, if the U.S. workplace was designed as a system that doesn’t work for people of color, then why are we looking for solutions (like psychological safety) within that same system?

Psychological safety is often promised but inconsistently realized, especially for People of the Global Majority (PoGM,) so we are introducing the concept of Psychological Agency as a more nuanced and relevant framework and a way to create a container where people who hold non-dominant culture identities can (1) exist within this insidious system without losing their sense of self and (2) reimagine what our workplace experience can be. While psychological safety emphasizes creating environments where individuals feel free to express themselves without fear, Psychological Agency shifts the focus inward, highlighting individuals’ autonomy over how, when, and to what extent they choose to bring their authentic selves into workplace settings.

This distinction is critical since U.S. workplaces are shaped by ideological systems such as white supremacy and capitalism, which inherently limit the scope of psychological safety for PoGM.

Psychological Agency is less about conforming to these structures and more about reclaiming agency over self, navigating workplace dynamics with intentionality, and making strategic decisions about our own authenticity.

Through Psychological Agency, individuals can foster a sense of self-efficacy within environments that may not be designed for full inclusion.

Psychological Safety

Researchers have examined the concept and practice of psychological safety with far-reaching applications across organizational settings dating back to the 1950s. Our current understanding of psychological safety largely stems from the work of Amy C. Edmondson (1999) and Timothy R. Clark (2020), who highlighted the need for people within organizations to have safety in taking interpersonal risks and shared accountability for creating a climate of safety. Edmondson helped shape psychological safety into an organizational development and culture framework that connected team productivity, performance, and outcomes to the level of psychological safety that exists within that team. Clark introduced the four stages of psychological safety to better understand the patterns of human behavior in organizational contexts: Inclusion Safety, Learner Safety, Contributor Safety, and Challenger Safety.

Limitations of Psychological Safety

We identified four limitations of psychological safety (not an exhaustive list) that moved us to explore a different framework, especially for people of color in the U.S. workplace.

  1. Psychological safety’s framing assumes that individuals are on a level playing field and that their experiences will be the same for everyone regardless of identity, positional power, and status. However, this framing can overlook the influence that power, privilege, and oppression have within environments that create different experiences for marginalized groups.
  2. Psychological safety may be unrealistic as an idealized state because organizations and people within them consistently change with the broader societal context. It can be difficult to imagine an organization that’s psychologically safe when the conditions required to do so are so fragile, like with external factors that can change at any time.
  3. Taking that second limitation a step further, we are currently experiencing multiple compounding systemic factors that influence how we perceive psychological safety in the workplace. It doesn’t make a difference how much a workplace says it embeds psychological safety into the fabric of its culture. The truth is that we’re facing an impending recession, rising inflation, 30% of households live paycheck to paycheck, healthcare is tied to our employment status, and almost every U.S. state is an at-will employment state.
  4. Finally, most critiques are missing that organizations exist within a society rooted in white supremacy, patriarchy, and capitalism. Those who are proximate to and/or benefit from upholding these systems will typically seek and reap the rewards that come from their conformity and compliance with those same systems. Others who challenge these systems are penalized and ostracized.

The behaviors, practices, policies, and expectations of organizations will always prioritize approximation to these ideological systems versus the humanity of individuals who exist within those systems.

What is Psychological Agency?

We find that the conditions required to experience true psychological safety are unattainable. The organizations we work in are a byproduct of the systems they operate in. If those systems don’t change, we cannot expect our organizations to shift to operate in a manner that is counter to or in opposition to those systems. Instead, we offer an alternative as a way to exist within oppressive organizations and systems, while still feeling some of the benefits that psychological safety aims to offer. The alternative is Psychological Agency.

We define Psychological Agency as the ability for us to decide how much of ourselves we bring to work, when we do it, who gets to experience our whole selves, and to what degree.

We have the agency to determine these conditions for ourselves, and if we decide to minimize ourselves, to make ourselves less visible, or to whitewash our personalities, intonation, and emotions, it is a strategy because we choose to do so, not because our coworkers are telling us or expecting us to.

Having the choice to decide how we operate within the system gives us the opportunity to reclaim our power.

Conclusion

This article is a dynamic piece that encompasses our thoughts, conversations, and research over the last two years. We recognize that our ideas are only scratching the surface, and we are open to constructive feedback and ongoing conversations as we strengthen the foundation and applicability of this topic. We felt the current narrative around psychological safety was lacking something, so it was important for us to contribute to the conversation now and offer a framework that centers PoGM and how we, collectively, reimagine it.

References

1 Teaching Tip Sheet: Self-Efficacy

2 Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams

3 The Four Stages of Psychological Safety

4 Nearly half of Americans say they live paycheck to paycheck

 

About the Author

+ posts

Andrea Pérez-Maikkula (she/her/ella) is a multilingual DEI practitioner with eighteen years of experience in intercultural facilitation, community engagement, and international community development, particularly in Haiti, where she focused her work on ecological sanitation. Born and raised in Puerto Rico, she currently serves as the Director of Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging (DEIB) at a State of Minnesota agency, is the Champion for the Black, Indigenous, and Women of Color (BIWOC) Employee Resource Group (ERG) enterprise-wide, and was appointed by Governor Walz to the One Minnesota Council on Diversity, Inclusion, and Equity. Andrea also serves as the Chair of the Human Rights Commission at the City of Brooklyn Park. Andrea holds a bachelor’s degree in business law and music business from the University of Miami and a master’s degree in public health from the University of Puerto Rico.

Jerad Green (he/him/his) is a seasoned diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) leader with over a decade of experience in higher education, government, and healthcare. As a practitioner, Jerad leads initiatives that embed equity and inclusion into organizational strategy, culture, and operations. He is the founder of Quixotic Solutions LLC, a consulting practice that helps organizations build actionable, sustainable DEI strategies. Jerad is passionate about creating environments where everyone can thrive, particularly by centering the needs of historically excluded communities. He believes investing in the well-being of minoritized groups elevates outcomes for all, and he brings this vision into every space he leads. Jerad is a proud alumnus of Winona State University and the University of Missouri - Kansas City.