I’m a dependable sucker for the Oscars. In addition to being a DEI (Diversity, Equity, Inclusion) practitioner for over two decades, I’ve been a lover of movies my entire life. And every January, when the Oscar nominations are announced, I pore over them. Then I read about who was nominated, who was snubbed, and who the industry insiders think will win. Next, I make a plan for the next two months, checking off the films I’ve already seen and figuring out how many nominated movies I can squeeze in before the ceremony in March. I have lots of opinions about past nominees and winners, who deserved their awards, who didn’t, and who should have won in their place (#Justice4GlennClose).

This year, the big news on January 23 was the 13 nominations for Jacques Audiard’s Emilia Pérez, a record for a non-English language film, and particularly the Best Actress nomination for Karla Sofía Gascón, the first transgender woman to be nominated for an acting Oscar. For years, activists have been imploring the film industry to cast trans actors to play trans roles. Firstly, trans actors face barriers being cast to play cisgender people, so it seems only fair that they should be considered first when vying for the opportunity to portray a trans character on screen. But perhaps more importantly, one of the reasons that trans people in society face marginalization and increased threats of violence is the belief that by being their authentic selves, they are actually “gender imposters,” essentially deceiving people about their “true” gender. For example, casting Jared Leto to play a transgender woman in Dallas Buyers Club (a role that won him an Oscar) feeds into that stereotype and puts trans people at even greater risk. So Gascón’s nomination was not only historic, but a hopeful sign (to me, anyway) that more trans actors would represent their own community on screen going forward.

Of particular interest to me was the fact that Gascón played a trans woman both before and after her transition. When we first see Karla Sofía Gascón on screen, she is playing the leader of a Mexican drug cartel who presents as male and introduces themself as “Manitas,” or “little hands.” Manitas hires Rita (Best Supporting Actress nominee Zoe Saldaña) to arrange for a gender transition to be performed in secret. Once all of the arrangements are made, Manitas fakes their own death, sends their wife (Selena Gomez) and two children to Switzerland, and goes into hiding. Then, the film jumps forward four years, and we witness the reunion of Rita and her former employer, who has since changed her name to Emilia. Emilia is happy living as her authentic self but misses her children (who believe their father to be dead), and so hires Rita once again – this time, to bring her family from Switzerland back to Mexico, where she will introduce herself as a cousin of their late husband and father.

I saw Emilia Pérez before the Oscar nominations were announced. My initial impression was mixed. It’s certainly an original invention. In addition to being a coming out story about a trans woman and a gritty drama about the drug trade, it’s also a musical, and it’s not uncommon for people who watch it to experience a form of “genre whiplash” as the film takes some wild zigs and zags. The musical numbers are not great (one song that details Rita’s efforts to secure a doctor for Emilia’s gender reassignment surgery, is particularly cringeworthy), and the tonal shifts don’t always work. But I thought the performances were terrific, especially Karla Sofía Gascón in the title role.

However, since the nominations were announced, criticisms of the film and its lead performer have been mounting. The movie was made by a French writer/director, and although it is set mostly in Mexico, it was filmed in France. Mexican audiences were largely offended by the lack of cultural competence involved. They didn’t like the stereotypical depiction of a drug cartel, or that the lead roles were played by actors from Spain (Gascón) and the United States (Saldaña and Gomez). In addition, transgender audiences disliked the conflation of Emilia’s gender transition with using her “new” identity to deceive her wife and children.

But mostly, the critiques were focused on Karla Sofía Gascón herself. After she made with her nomination, her old social media posts from 2020 and 2021 began to surface. These included offensive statements about Islam, the murder of George Floyd, the COVID pandemic, and the diversity present at the 2020 Academy Awards. Her remarks took aim at Muslims, Chinese people, Black Lives Matter activists, and others. Initially, she offered no comment about these remarks but later apologized and deleted her social media accounts. Still, it seems the damage has been done. Netflix has removed her from their Oscar campaign, and it’s a real possibility that her film, once an Oscar front-runner, will score zero wins.

A lot is happening in the world right now, and I agree with anyone who points out that a failed campaign for Academy Awards should not be chief among our worries in 2025. But I do feel as though the whole saga is instructive, should we seek to learn some lessons from it. For instance, I was hardly alone when I sat down to watch a film that took place mostly in Mexico, presented mostly in Spanish, and accepted it as a valid depiction of Mexican culture. As a cisgender viewer, I accepted the basic plot of the film without thinking about the danger that is present whenever trans people are depicted first and foremost as liars and deceivers.

Finally, when I registered my disappointment over Karla Sofía Gascón’s problematic statements from the past, I was reminded that not every person from an oppressed group can or should be trusted to be a leader on the topic of human rights for all. I was also reminded of people I’ve met who have disappointed me in similar ways, and that being marginalized because of one identity does not erase the privilege you might gain from another.

About the Author

+ posts

Eric Peterson is a consultant with The Winters Group, Inc., and a recognized facilitator and educator in the diversity and inclusion space with over 20 years of experience in implicit bias, diversity and inclusion, learning strategies, and organization development. Eric’s former and current clients include advertising firms, member associations, government agencies, healthcare organizations, performing arts organizations, technology firms, telecommunications companies. He has expertise in implicit bias, power dynamics, allyship, the LGBTQ community, and whiteness as a social identity.