
There’s a little game I like to play when I’m meeting a gay man for the first time. It’s not really a game, so much as an icebreaker, a way to ease into conversation and immediately get to know them a bit better. And it almost always works. And it’s a simple question: “Who’s your diva?”
Most gay men immediately know what I mean. There’s an entire pantheon of female entertainers throughout our shared history that have courted and earned the affection of the gay male audience. They’re fierce, they’re fabulous. We love them and they love us back.
I’ve long theorized that we worship our divas because they show us that strength does not require masculinity. Divas are tough without being stereotypically gruff. For many of us, especially in our youth, this was an important lesson. As a group, our divas have a lot in common – but taken individually, there’s much that makes them distinct. Bette Midler, for instance, is bawdy in a way that Diana Ross would never. Kate Bush’s airy soprano is as ethereal as Madonna’s sex-positive anthems are carnal.
And while most gay men are fans of many divas, the whole point of my icebreaker is to ask them to choose just one – one icon that stands above the rest, the queen of their own personal fandom. And while I haven’t exactly mapped out all the ways a gay man’s diva of choice could define his personality, I think some of the patterns are fairly obvious. I learn a whole lot more about a gay man with this question than I’d ever get from “where did you grow up?” or “what do you do [for a living]?” This question is about where he gets his strength and his joy, which isn’t something we always associate with our hometowns or workplaces.
For instance, I have a longtime friend whose diva is Cher. When I ask him to tell me about Cher and why he loves her, his first instinct is to typically do an impression (actually, an impression or drag queen Chad Michaels imitating Cher), braying, “Because I’m Cher, bitch!” He loves her outspokenness, her ability to say whatever is on her mind and get away with it, and the way she shocks people with her outrageous fashion choices and one-liners. In an oddly reflective moment (for him), he also said how much he admired that she initially struggled with her son’s journey as a transgender man, revealing that even our idols aren’t always perfect.
Okay, so that’s Cher. So, who is my friend? Well, he’s outspoken, he seems incapable of not saying whatever is on his mind (he doesn’t get away with it quite as often as she does), and he delights in shocking people. He can also be a bit of a perfectionist, which is perhaps why he appreciated her rare moments of imperfection.
Another friend struggled a bit with this question when I first asked it. He wasn’t sure he had a favorite, but after some time to think, he asked me, “Would Angela Lansbury count?” And of course, I told him OF COURSE she counts, and what an inspired choice she was. Lest you’re like most men my age (Gen X) or younger, who mainly associate Ms. Lansbury with solving cozy mysteries in Cabot Cove, Maine (a quaint little town with a surprisingly high homicide rate), my friend was much more inclined to think of Angela singing “The Worst Pies in London” on the original cast album of Sweeney Todd. He had also seen her play the bad girl in Gaslight and The Harvey Girls, and her shocking turn in The Manchurian Candidate (if you haven’t seen it, please do it now before anyone spoils it).
Okay, so that’s Angela Lansbury. So, who’s this friend? Well, he’s a lot quieter than the first friend, but with a rapier wit that reveals itself occasionally and always to devastating effect. People who don’t know him well think of him as demure and kind (which he is, at least the “kind” part), but those of us who know him well also delight in his caustic asides (usually muttered underneath his breath and followed with the most innocent of smiles).
And who is your favorite diva and what does it all mean? Well, if you say Ella Fitzgerald, the singer who sang the entire American Songbook with impeccable precision but never cared too much about developing a stage persona, I’m going to assume that you prefer substance over style. If you say Kylie Minogue, I’m probably going to guess that you embody (or at least aspire to) longevity and work ethic without ever sacrificing a sense of fun or taking yourself too seriously. If you say Beyoncé, I’m going to posit that you value creating a self that works for you without ever forgetting where you came from. Or maybe I’m way off, and the reason you made those choices have completely different origins, and the ensuing conversation will be a whole lot more interesting than a rundown of your résumé.
As the originator of this game (at least as far as I know), I’ll cheat a little bit and say that I’m a Liza Minnelli with a moon in Bette Davis and Madonna rising (what exactly that says about me is probably better left to my friends to explain). But if pressed, Liza is the diva I’ve given my whole heart to. I’ve seen Cabaret about 50 times, saw her live on three separate occasions, and I recently received a signed copy of her memoir in the mail, which I devoured in three days. So … the next time you meet a gay man and honestly couldn’t care less where he was born or what his college major was, just ask him who his diva is. Ask him what makes her so special. You might not learn everything about him in that moment, but it’s a whole lot more fun than talking about your jobs.
About the Author
Eric Peterson is a consultant with The Winters Group, Inc., and a recognized facilitator and educator in the diversity and inclusion space with over 20 years of experience in implicit bias, diversity and inclusion, learning strategies, and organization development. Eric’s former and current clients include advertising firms, member associations, government agencies, healthcare organizations, performing arts organizations, technology firms, telecommunications companies. He has expertise in implicit bias, power dynamics, allyship, the LGBTQ community, and whiteness as a social identity.
